Minority Rule

While most see the collapse of Syria as just another Middle East country thrown into chaos by the American government, it is a good lesson in the dangers that come when a distinct minority rules over the majority. The ISIS rebels get the credit, but the real blame lies with the way in which the Syria state was structured. Until now, Syria was ruled by one of the many minorities in the region. That minority is a mysterious ethnoreligious group called the Alawites.

The place to start is with the people. Syria has some of the oldest communities in the world, dating back to the ancient world. Maaloula, a village in western Syria, is one of the last remaining places where Aramaic is spoken. There are Christian communities that date back to Rome. Of course, Islam has been in the area now called Syria since the time of Mohamed. There is also the ethnoreligious group called the Alawites, which split from Shia Islam at some unknown point in the past.

The origins and identity of the Alawites are a mystery. There are roughly four million of them in the region. Their legends say they are descendants of the followers of the eleventh Imam, Hasan al-Askari. The reason he is called the eleventh Iman is because he was one of the twelve imams who claimed to be the spiritual and biological successors of the Mohamed. These are the founders of Shia Islam. Exactly how they became this distinct subgroup within Islam remains a mystery.

Now, Shia Islam is itself a minority within Islam. Roughly ten percent of all Muslim belong to a sect within the Shia designation. The vast majority of Muslims, especially in the Arab world, are Sunnis. Unsurprisingly, the relations between the Sunnis and Shia have never been good. One result of this enmity between the two camps is that the Sunnis, who make up seventy percent of Syria, claim the Alawites are not just heretics and non-believers, but not even Arabs.

That last claim is not without some merit. There has been a great deal of effort to gloss over the ethnic realities in that part of the world. Western experts are sure that there is no such thing as biological reality, so differences in people, even genetic differences, are explained as cultural differences. The locals, however, understand that the Levant has been the land of invaders, and they left behind more than just their buildings and some of their cultural practices.

That aside, the Alawites have been a highly clannish and resourceful group, often creating problems for the local rulers. The Ottomans tried to suppress them on multiple occasions, but also found them useful in roles requiring skill, like tax farming and managing the empire’s finances. When the Europeans came to dominate the region in the 19th century, the Alawites proved useful to their new rulers. It turns out that every ruler needs smart and clever people.

It is this ability to run complex systems that eventually allowed the Alawites to take control of Syria. That and their clannishness. Under the French, the Alawites played a key role, which gave them access to power and resources. After independence, their resourcefulness and understanding of the systems left by the Europeans allowed Hafez al-Assad and his Ba’ath Party to seize power. The Alawites, despite their numbers, were smarter than their rivals.

As an aside, one of the many claims about the Alawites by the Muslim majority is that they supported Israeli independence and had a long working relationship with the Jews in the region. This is generally considered a smear, but it is clear that the Alawites were willing to work with other minority groups in the region. The Assad family famously protected the Christian communities in Syria, for example. Minorities have a funny habit of sticking together against the majority.

That aside, a country run by a distinct and distrusted minority is never going to be stable, especially when the minority is tiny. This is why the Assad government had been ruthless at times when dealing with the Sunni majority. To keep the peace, the government had to make clear to anyone thinking otherwise that the government would use maximum force to maintain the peace. Minority rule is always made worse by the tactics necessary to maintain it.

Of course, the Assad led Syria had been useful to the West for a long time, so they got the support they needed to maintain themselves. Until now, it had been assumed that chaos in Syria would be bad for the region and bad for Israel. As a rule, confident countries seek stability in their diplomacy. Now that the official policy of the United States is to spread chaos around the world, Assad was an easy target for the now familiar regime change operation.

Regime change was possible in Syria because it was a minority government ruling a hostile majority. Western sanctions starved Syria of the cash it needed to bribe enough of the majority into supporting them. Turkish and American terror groups operating within Syria put constant pressure on the government. The reason Assad fell so quickly to this hodgepodge of ISIS radicals is the Alawite system collapsed. The ISIS mob was simply the straw that broke the camel’s back.

This is what makes Syria a timeless lesson. No society run by a distinct minority can be stable, as the majority will always distrust that minority. Even when minority rule results in good times, as in the case of colonial Africa, the majority will find reasons to resent that minority. In fact, the good times allows that resentment to slowly build under the surface of apparent tranquility. As soon as bad times come, the majority revolts and the laws of large numbers takes its course.

Syria is why the Israelis have no interest in ruling over Arabs. They could take control of Gaza and the West Bank, for example, but they would be viewed as a minority ruling a hostile majority, so expulsion is their preferred option. In the oldest part of the world, the people still understand the oldest lessons. One of those is that a minority ruling a majority must always be a temporary condition. In the end, numbers always matter more than even human capital. The majority wins in the end.


If you like my work and wish to donate, you can buy me a beer. You can sign up for a SubscribeStar or a Substack subscription and get some extra content. You can donate via PayPal. My crypto addresses are here for those who prefer that option. You can send gold bars through the postal service to: Z Media LLC P.O. Box 1047 Berkeley Springs, WV 25411-3047. Thank you for your support!


**Promotions: **Good Svffer is an online retailer partnering with several prolific content creators on the Dissident Right, both designing and producing a variety of merchandise including shirts, posters, and books. If you are looking for a way to let the world know you are one of us without letting the world know you are one one is us, then you should but a shirt with the Lagos Trading Company logo.

Minter & Richter Designs makes high-quality, hand-made by one guy in Boston, titanium wedding rings for men and women and they are now offering readers a fifteen percent discount on purchases if you use this link. If you are headed to Boston, they are also offering my readers 20% off their 5-star rated Airbnb.  Just email them directly to book at sa@******************ns.com.


To keep Z Man's voice alive for future generations, we’ve archived his writings from the original site at thezman.com. We’ve edited out ancillary links, advertisements, and donation requests to focus on his written content.

Comments (Historical)

The comments below were originally posted to thezman.com.

108 Comments

Tykebomb #435696 December 11, 2024 10:03 am 72
The saddest thing about learning about American involvement in the Middle East, hell with Muslims generally, is that the Iranians may have a point with this “Great Satan” business. At every chance, if the USG can fuck over the native Christians, that’s the option chosen. Always.
Lucius Sulla #435706 December 11, 2024 10:23 am 37
I was looking that up today – the decimation of Christian populations in places the (((United States))) creates chaos. Syria’s Christian population has declined 75% since 2011 Iraq’s Christian population has declined from ~1.5MM to less than 250k since 2003 And of course, for (((OUR GREATEST ALLY))), Christian population was near 8% in 1948, now less than 2%
Xman #435720 December 11, 2024 11:04 am 40
Yeah, one need not endorse the Muslim nutjobs and fanatics, of which there are many, to see that they have a point. Exactly what does ZOG offer them? Feminism, pornography, promiscuity, homosexuality, consumerism, Zionism, usury, and financial swindles if they go along with the program and become “democratic,” and death from the ZOG military of they don’t.
Ostei Kozelskii #435728 December 11, 2024 11:28 am 17
ZOG also offers them the opportunity to import as many Hutus as possible. What’s not to love?!
Spingerah #435765 December 11, 2024 1:17 pm 6
I always thought it was tutsies.Oh well who can tell the diferance anyway.
Ostei Kozelskii #435769 December 11, 2024 2:34 pm 3
Oh, I’d much prefer to import them.
Citizen of a Silly Country #435691 December 11, 2024 9:45 am 68
That aside, a country run by a distinct and distrusted minority is never going to be stable, especially when the minority is tiny. Unless that minority can pretend to be a part of the majority. Neat trick.
RealityRules #435699 December 11, 2024 10:08 am 14
Yes. But recent events with Buh-Buh-Buh-Buh Benjamin’s Buh-Buh-Buh-Buh foreign media star and reservation gatekeeper agent show that the enlisted minorities are hip to the game. Even if the fading and as yet cowed majority will not dare say things much less even dare to claim they are a distinct ethnic/racial group, these enlisted minority coalition partners smell blood and they are setting fires in the bushes to flush out the game.As enraging as it is that the still majority doesn’t have a single person with the moral courage to explicitly declare themselves a champion of a distinct ethnic/racial group, it is amusing to watch the gollum’s expose the highly competent minority. It is a guilty pleasure to watch them squirm and admit that they are White but it depends on what you mean by White. It is only a matter of time before even the junior partners figure out that the equivocation means I am when I need to cloak myself to them and I am not when I want to separate myself for protected class purposes.I suspect some clever Tweeting and message board trolling could show the junior partners that certain practices go back into ancient times. In fact, it could be pointed out that pre-meditated genocidal conquest as well as beguiling the outsiders by dividing the clan and going amongst them as friends are both well documented in the Good Book.As Z points out, at some point tyranny must be overtly rolled out to keep the lid on the pot. That will only draw attention to the steam and the lid rattling over on the burner. Bribes work, until diminishing returns and, well, you know what they say about the Danegeld. At some point, the tyranny is very likely to be turned against its architects and initial stewards.Interesting times. We need to keep our heads down and focus on self preservation. For now it is families and the awakened in emergent networks building resilience for the purpose of self preservation. The numbers will grow. For the rest, it is out of our hands now.
Citizen of a Silly Country #435703 December 11, 2024 10:19 am 29
The internet has helped awaken a lot of people. It doesn’t take a lot to show the deception, and there’s not really a response to prove otherwise. It’s why the gatekeepers have such a hard time and do everything that they can to change the subject rather refute the claim. There’s also the rise of other minorities. The Indians are coming, indeed have arrived. They know who they’re deal with. Heck, they use them as role model. There’s already tension. King Cobra doesn’t want to be some lawn jockey.
Wolf Barney #435711 December 11, 2024 10:44 am 14
Where would we be without the internet, along with the portable video camera everyone carries in their pocket? Sharing copies of the Culture of Critique I guess!
Alzaebo #435729 December 11, 2024 11:31 am 32
Ha! What is today’s meme?“Breaking:In a highly usual event, a Penny escapes from a Jew.” Another notes that in the side-by-side of Daniel and Dafna, Daniel even looks like a Greek god.
Spingerah #435751 December 11, 2024 12:45 pm 2
Brilliant. Forwarded to friends & family with a quickness.
RealityRules #435744 December 11, 2024 12:08 pm 4
Yes. And even though he was shut up and forced to change his tune to ascend and consolidate a position of political power, that doesn’t mean he has changed his mind. It probably means he has given extra notice and has a seething resentment for being put in his place. He isn’t the first, he isn’t the last. Whack-a-mole will only lead to more noticing by more and more powerful people who are ascendent.
HalfTrolling #435731 December 11, 2024 11:43 am 7
Once they go mask off even the dumbest of white normies is gonna figure the game out, and its curtins for them.
c matt #435775 December 11, 2024 3:54 pm 4
Schrodingstein’s White.
Jeffrey Zoar #435705 December 11, 2024 10:21 am 27
I doubt a very high percentage of AINO residents could answer with any accuracy the question of who rules over them. Certainly a ridiculously high percentage would say the president, or congress, or something stupid like that. Even the ones who know it is not those entities (including me) still have a tough time pinning it down with any specificity. Thus it is somewhat superfluous that they pretend to be part of the majority, since nobody knows they (or which of them) are in charge anyway.
Mr. House #435710 December 11, 2024 10:35 am 3
https://youtu.be/35DSdw7dHjs
Tom K #435740 December 11, 2024 11:58 am 4
That’s a great scene. If one looks at let’s call it the globalist impulse, then things like corporations, fiat money, mass media, and now AI are just tools to further degrade the self-integrity of each person on the planet. Maybe AI is the final tool to complete the job of making the entirety of humanity into a mindless hive and the globalists will succeed in their dream of a universal government. On second thought, nah.
Alzaebo #435762 December 11, 2024 1:01 pm 0
Okay, I’ll look.Please give us a header with random vids, Mr. House. Update: Ah. A scene from ‘Network’, the “We’re mad as hell” movie. Never seen it, so thanks, will watch.
Tars Tarkas #435727 December 11, 2024 11:25 am 9
People cannot identify it because it’s not really a single ethnic group (minority) that is ruling over us. This is where I part ways with the antisemites who are sure the ruling ethnicity is the small hats. They have disproportionate power, but they are only part of it. It’s a coalition of freaks, various minorities and traitorous White people. When we win, our modern Sobibor will be a utopia couse it will be a very diverse place.
LineInTheSand #435733 December 11, 2024 11:44 am 25
The anti-Israel protests on our campuses certainly demonstrate your point that no one group exerts decisive control on all issues. It’s interesting to try to watch the internal conflicts between these groups to determine their relative strengths. Black women supported OJ, to the surprise of white feminists, for example. Is there a single cause that makes these disparate groups allies? It seems like there must be. I submit that the cause that binds them is hatred of traditional whites.
ray #435748 December 11, 2024 12:34 pm 15
They make no secret of their binding glue. Read their (endless) screeds, articles and dissertations. Note their targets in the workplaces, schools, courts. They are organized around a seething resentment of, and hatred for, straight white males . . . though in general they hate masculinity across-the-board. Especially they hate Christian white males, because these are the remnant representatives of Hateful Oppressor Patriarchy. Which exists exactly nowhere in New Amerika. But that’s the straw man they keep burning down.
Ostei Kozelskii #435754 December 11, 2024 12:51 pm 14
White women are under the gun, too. The clitoris is no amulet to ward off the capital charge of whiteness.
ray #435778 December 11, 2024 4:16 pm 6
I don’t see it, amigo, but I appreciate your response. White women in America are the most privileged, empowered and entitled group — outside of ‘royalty’ — that has ever existed on Earth.Corporations and academia and the general workplace aren’t blacklisting them (like white males) but welcoming them with open arms. For fifty years and counting.In the second half of the 20th Century, white women ruled America and were the front lines of P.C., when it was called that. The heart ‘n soul of the Demoncrapic Party.White women were the giddy, joyfully dancing nurses during their beloved Plandemic. Enraptured by the attention and power the Scamdemic brought, and many look back on the lockdowns, masks and distancing with longing.As they gobble anti-depressants fruitlessly.If the open-border invasion continues as the regime’s holy grail, and the elite turns to the Of Color Female, then I can see a day when white women may feel what it’s like truly to be oppressed and abused. Right now they’re the Gold Standard, unmerited.
Ostei Kozelskii #435787 December 11, 2024 4:56 pm 8
Compared to non-whites, white women are anything but privileged for the simple reason that they are tainted by whiteness. AINO’s most privileged people are negroes and pervs of various and sundry stripe. When it comes to the Left’s victim/oppressor matrix, white women are classed in the second category, although like Jews, many of them don’t realize it.And while it’s true that white women were dreadful Kovid Karens and most HR shrews are also white women, it is also true that they voted for Trump 53/46 despite intense pressure from the Power Structure to vote their plumbing rather than their race. Having done so will only solidify their position in the Left’s crosshairs.
ray #435796 December 11, 2024 8:31 pm 1
I think a lot of white females that voted Trump truly were worried that the combo of the elites and the Progs were gonna finish-off America, with open borders, DEI, intentional inflation and all the rest. Many of those women held their noses and voted for Donald. They were less interested in seating a black female president than in continuing their relatively easy lives.
The Wild Geese Howard #435799 December 11, 2024 10:02 pm 1
Really? Posts like this make me feel like I need to start channeling the old school version of Whiskey.
Steve W #435781 December 11, 2024 4:33 pm 7
Blacks will only support other blacks if the political litmus test has been passed. Which tells me that blacks do as they’re told, by someone… it’s not like they are innately liberal Democrats, bound to suburban white shitlibs by some common view of life.When Larry Elder challenged Gavin Newsome in a recall referendum, the LA Times and other media outlets dubbed him “the black face of white supremacy.” Blacks voted overwhelmingly for the governor.At a guess, if instead of murdering two people, OJ decided to go into politics and run as a Republican, he’d have likewise been called “the black face of white supremacy” or maybe – as Clarence Thomas was called by a magazine targeted to blacks in the nineties (I forget the name) – “a lawn jockey of the far right.”Blacks, in the aggregate, are easily confused by their thought managers. They’ll go all in on the blackity black except when not, because reasons.
LineInTheSand #435793 December 11, 2024 5:59 pm 2
Their tribalism rejects traitors. Elder and Thomas are regarded as traitors to their tribe.
ray #435747 December 11, 2024 12:27 pm -13
‘The Jews’ don’t run the U.S. Those elements of Jewry that are organized generally behind Sabbatean Frankism and Talmudism exert influence in specific spheres, and most certainly are eschatological obsessives concerning their dogma. But the shots are called at the international or global level.
Scrooge McDuck #435758 December 11, 2024 12:57 pm 14
By Larry Fink at Blackrock.$20 trillion in managed assets.
Tars Tarkas #435770 December 11, 2024 2:52 pm -1
It’s like you didn’t read a single freakin word I wrote. What part of “This is where I part ways with the antisemites who are sure the ruling ethnicity is the small hats.” didn’t you understand?
ray #435779 December 11, 2024 4:24 pm -2
Yes, I understood what you said the first time that I read it.
c matt #435777 December 11, 2024 4:04 pm 11
Yes and no. The best way to think of jews controlling the US is akin to a publicly traded company. Sure, Exxon may have 120,000,000 different shareholders. But if one shareholder holds 5% of the stock, and the next largest shareholder has 0.1% of the stock, guess who has effective control?
Justinian #435843 December 12, 2024 11:13 am 0
What a comedy post is that .
Justinian #435849 December 12, 2024 11:24 am 0
Usa is the first ” Christian ” established empire completely owned by the Jews .They own everything in any sphere. Financial, industrial and cultural( garbage of the highest order )THEY OWN USA 100 PERCENT. IF YOU CANN MENTION ONE IMPORTANT THING THEY DO NOT OWN JUST GIVE EXAMPLE. THEY OWN OF COURSE THE GOVERNMENT 100 PERCENT AS WELL .THAT OF COURSE MADE USA ” THE GREAT SATAN” .What it is .Usa destroyed the great European Christian civilization for the jews in Second World War.THEY FOUGHT ON THE SIDE OF EVIL .Of course with help destroy that they actually destroyed themselves as they are absolute product of European Christian civilization.
c matt #435776 December 11, 2024 3:59 pm 14
But whom are you not allowed to criticize?
Citizen of a Silly Country #435785 December 11, 2024 4:50 pm 8
Yep. All those other supposedly powerful groups don’t mess with the Jews. Jews don’t control everything, but they control what they care about.
Tars Tarkas #435788 December 11, 2024 5:32 pm -2
Yes, I agree. Criticism of them is severely punished in short order.There are no shortages of Jews who are a problem. They do have control of certain things. But they have lots and lots of help. There are lots of other bad actors. In short, they are a problem, but they are not THE problem as the antisemites like to say. At least in my opinion.
Mr. House #435800 December 11, 2024 10:10 pm 0
Well if you’re married, that would be your wife. Otherwise you’ll end of divorced minus half your money.
Citizen of a Silly Country #435783 December 11, 2024 4:47 pm 12
Agree and disagree. Here’s where I agree. Jews don’t control everything. Let’s not give them more credit than they are due. Yes, there are other powerful factions among the elite.However, I disagree in the sense that no other faction of the elite is 1) as cohesive; 2) multi-generational; 3) as willing to blackmail and threaten; and 4) has an intelligence agency (Mossad) with all the things that a good intelligence agency can do working for it.Jews are only one of several powerful groups in the US, but they operate at a very different level. No other group can go toe to toe with them. They are the apex predator of the elite.
HalfTrolling #435735 December 11, 2024 11:45 am 10
we’re not rules by individuals but by a class. So its impossible to pick one of them out, point at them and say, its him officer. Its also why there have been no “great men” in the era of managerial rule, there are no individuals in this class who can BE great men.
Tired Citizen #435791 December 11, 2024 5:45 pm 2
Who are you not allowed to criticize?
Templar #435732 December 11, 2024 11:43 am -6
Neat trick, and one the Jews have been famous for doing for literally thousands of years. Survival strategy and all that. Quit being coy, you sound dumb.
The Greek #435737 December 11, 2024 11:48 am 30
I disagree with this sentiment. They pretend to be part of the majority when it benefits them, and then pretend to be minorities when that benefits them.The real differences with America’s situation compared to Syria is two pronged.1) The Alawites were in charge, and this wasn’t obfuscated or lied about. Everyone knew. In America, they’ve done a neat trick where they’ve largely convinced the majority that they’re actually the ones in control, and all the poor minorities are still brutally repressed. This is despite the fact that we see all the systemic discrimination against the majority in government and private corporations. Don’t believe your lying eyes, or you’re a bad person.2) They’re actively engaged in a plan to turn the majority into a minority. Something the alawites never had a prayer of doing.
Mr. House #435763 December 11, 2024 1:03 pm 5
“They pretend to be part of the majority when it benefits them, and then pretend to be minorities when that benefits them.” cowardly conduct, most normally observed in females
Citizen of a Silly Country #435786 December 11, 2024 4:52 pm 10
Read Curt Doolittle. He argues (correctly in my opinion) that Jews (and Semites in general) employ a feminine style of warfare. Subversion, propaganda, etc., rather than direct attacks. Granted, the Israelis use masculine warfare at times, but they’re kind of forced to do that. They prefer regime change.
Tired Citizen #435790 December 11, 2024 5:44 pm 2
Only when it’s beneficial.
mikew #435719 December 11, 2024 11:03 am 26
The US commenced Operation Timber Sycamore. Our CIA spent 1 billion on weapons arming rebels (AQ and later ISIS) to overthrow Assad. The Arabs assisted the rebs as did Israel and Turkey. Later, the US sent troops in , ostensibly to fight ISIS but we took control of their relatively small but still lucrative oil fields and deprived Assad of revenue. Of course Russia assisted and turned the tide but sanctions and loss of oil revenue prevented Assad from even paying his army at the end. Regardless of his minority status, Assad would still be in power in Syria if not for our intervention.
Dutchboy #435734 December 11, 2024 11:45 am 4
The US intervention was motivated by Israel’s desire to remove the pro-Hezbollah Assad regime. With Hezbollah isolated from their Iranian allies and thereby weakened, Israel would have an opportunity to seize southern Lebanon and its water resources, which Israel has long coveted. They might also get a slice of southern Syria in the bargain.
Assad #435756 December 11, 2024 12:53 pm 3
Yeah sure, but truth does not make a zman essay. Also the entire trouble started, when the “high-IQ” white governor from the whitest state became US president and even got re-elected to implement the promise of “bringing democracy to middle east”. Still everything is the fault of low-IQ blacks/browns, Alawite minorities and mischievous Jews. White Christian America needs to take responsibility for this entire middle-eastern mess. It was not created by Obama or blacks or Democrats. Alawites lost control because Europeans/Americans lost respect of the region.
Jack Boniface #435683 December 11, 2024 9:20 am 23
It’s similar to to how Saddam’s Tikriti clan, a minority within the Sunnis, who were a minority in majority-Shia Iraq, were put in power by the Brits. He then became a client of the Americans, who helped him in the Iraq-Iran War of the 1980s. When Washington got tired of him, he was lured by Ambassador April Glaspie into invading Kuwait, which sparked the 1990-91 Gulf War and all the rest.
Götterdamn-it-all #435715 December 11, 2024 10:59 am 1
I did an AI search on April Glaspie. Here is what came back…“Is April Glaspie Jewish?Based on the provided search results, there is no direct information indicating April Glaspie’s religious affiliation or ethnicity as Jewish. However, we can analyze the available information:The search results mention Paul Michael Glaser, an American actor and director, who is Jewish. However, there is no connection established between Paul Glaser and April Glaspie. April Glaspie’s biography does not mention her religious affiliation or ethnicity as Jewish. The search results do not provide any information suggesting a Jewish connection or heritage for April Glaspie.In the absence of explicit information, it is reasonable to conclude that there is no evidence to support the claim that April Glaspie is Jewish. If more information becomes available, it may shed light on her religious affiliation or ethnicity. However, based on the current search results, it appears that April Glaspie’s religious affiliation or ethnicity is not explicitly stated as Jewish.”Hmm…
Hemid #435764 December 11, 2024 1:05 pm 5
Remember when publicly available “AI” hadn’t yet been “aligned” (retarded) and its gaydar was almost infallible—stronger than the strongest pervert’s? That was AI’s first real breakthrough into public consciousness, its firsthit. (LOOK AT THESE FAGS, the headlines nearly shouted.) Now it can’t even look at pictures, because… Well, the excuse was: It thinks black women are gorillas because photography is racist. Racism in, gorillas out. Youcan still look at pictures, though. For now. Image-searching little-known political figures is noted in your permanent record.
c matt #435773 December 11, 2024 3:45 pm -2
\\\\\_____ )
mikew #435789 December 11, 2024 5:41 pm 2
I heard about Glaspie’s statements to Saddam sometime in the Fall of 90, well after the clearly fake “babies tossed out of incubators” story. It opened by eyes. I opposed the whole thing after all that because it stunk to high heaven. The early neocons of the time including Dick Cheney who was SecDef were already doing their tricks. Foreign troops not leaving Saudi afterwards was Osama’s stated motivation for 9/11. It is interesting to recall that Assad’s father sent Syrian troops to fight Saddam and I believe they and the Kuwait at large army, were the first to enter Kuwait City. All about appearances. The US displayed their gratitude with regime change.
Nikolai Vladivostok #435794 December 11, 2024 7:04 pm 4
American is a dangerous enemy a deadly friend.
Jeffrey Zoar #435722 December 11, 2024 11:11 am 15
You would have to look far and wide, probably in vain, to find another “majority” that hates each other as much as whites in AINO do. (Putting aside for the moment whether or not Luigi Mangione and I belong to the same ethnic group, he doesn’t look anything like me, not a similar name, but clown world says we are both “white,” whatever that’s supposed to mean). I’m not disagreeing with Zman when he saysAs soon as bad times come, the majority revolts.But here in AINO, it’s an open question if that applies, as I’m not sure that there is any majority. The closest we could hypothetically get to one is something like what we just saw at the ballot box where hispanic males align with whites. It’s why the possibilities for an American Caesar are dim; he can’t unite us when there is no us.
Pozymandias #435767 December 11, 2024 1:58 pm 10
The Achilles heel of European-derived people (what most just call “Whites”), is that their identity is almost entirely constructed along class, religious, or ideological lines. Virtually every other large group has some sort of tribalism as their primary self-identity. Tribalism is simply a code for race+culture. You can quibble about this and point out that Whites tend to form families within their class but it’s a matter of what comes first. For most people on the planet, their identity is mostly in their genes. For Euros, it’s something in their heads.This is of course, a huge weakness, because all that needs to happen is some group of outsiders to come along who are clever enough to manipulate Whites along class, religious, or ideological lines without themselves falling for the rhetorical tricks needed to achieve this. Now of course, no such group exists… Oh, who am I kidding. Of course (((they))) do. In fact, to paraphrase Voltaire, if they did not exist it would be necessary to invent them. Indeed Jews readily allow other groups to marry into their tribe so you could even make the case that Jews are, to some extent, self-invented themselves.Whites can’t defend themselves as an “us” because they’ve all been indoctrinated from birth to primarily hate other White groups. Even today, when I think of “the enemy”, I primarily picture some affluent WASPy Anglo shitlib from Boston or New York. Having interacted with these people from my youth, I can tell you that they feel the same about me (Italian/German Catholic and working class background). Whites will need to overcome these biases and realize that they are all being herded over a cliff by those outside their traditional ethnic rivalries.
c matt #435772 December 11, 2024 3:38 pm 3
I take the White thing much like the Arab saying of “me against my brother, etc.” It is somewhat defined by your opposition – Italian v. German, North Euro vs. South Euro (or East West), Euro v. Non-Euro. Sort of concentric circles. Or blast radius.
Alex #435695 December 11, 2024 10:03 am 15
Although its a footnote now, its also the end of Ba’athism in the Arab world.
Vicki Bryant #435688 December 11, 2024 9:44 am 15
I find this somewhat ironic; the population of a certain group of peoples is estimated at 2.2%, yet this minority seeks eminence and authority of all world governments. Will they too fail?
DLS #435717 December 11, 2024 11:00 am 8
Jews are 0.2% of the world population.
BigJimSportCamper #435743 December 11, 2024 12:01 pm 6
She may have meant in the US.
usNthem #435684 December 11, 2024 9:32 am 15
I kinda seems like we’re ruled over, or at least heavily influenced by a minority or two in this place. Will the declining White majority ever rebel? Time is running out.
Diversity Heretic #435687 December 11, 2024 9:38 am 9
Good comment! Whites in the US are in the process of becoming a mere plurality. Whether the “minority group” that presently governs the US can continue to rule over a brown-black majority is an open question, but my guess is no.I have heard reports that Israeli tanks are rather close to Damascus and that the US and Israel continue to systematically bomb Syrian military assets. I’m not certain how these new “liberators of Syria” will fare against an Israeli offensive, backed by the US. And I’ve also heard there is already fighting between Turks and Kurds in Syria. Sometimes events have a way of spiraling out of control.
DLS #435712 December 11, 2024 10:52 am 16
“Whether the “minority group” that presently governs the US can continue to rule over a brown-black majority is an open question, but my guess is no.” The president of Mexico is Claudia Sheinbaum.
ray #435753 December 11, 2024 12:48 pm 11
A feminist, enviro-globalist Jewess running Mexico. Something for the Little Brown People to look up to.
Ostei Kozelskii #435757 December 11, 2024 12:56 pm 19
In the Age of Derangement, is there anything more bizarre than a Jewess ruling the world’s leading mestizo patriarchy? There’s no way in Hell that “election” was on the up-and-up.
AnotherAnon #435792 December 11, 2024 5:47 pm 3
Keeping Kurds from the oil and also getting rid of some nettlesome Syrian refugees – some housekeeping Erdogan decided to move on to his advantage before Trump comes in. Turkey being in NATO is dumb beyond belief. But then NATO is now nothing but trouble anyway.
Barney Rubble #435716 December 11, 2024 10:59 am 28
For most Whites in the US, “rebellion” means voting for Orange Man and cheering when Kid Rock shoots some Bud Light cans. Let’s hope there are some serious people somewhere in the bowels of MAGA.
Ostei Kozelskii #435759 December 11, 2024 12:57 pm 16
Frankly, Kid Rock sounds like the name of Barney Rubble’s long lost grandson.
The Greek #435760 December 11, 2024 12:59 pm 7
I regularly bring up the idea of balkanization/peaceable separation of the country to MAGA types and get little pushback. They’re not as repulsed by it as a republican white would have been 20 years ago. My feeling is that they have this hope that Trump can bring back the America they remember, but they’re open to other options if he fails or things keep declining.
Arshad Ali #435689 December 11, 2024 9:45 am 13
“That aside, a country run by a distinct and distrusted minority is never going to be stable, especially when the minority is tiny.”Under Hafez Assad, there were some progressive reforms. For example state-subsidized electrification, made possible by the Euphrates dam. I got this nugget from Tariq Ali’s recent essay on Syria, who argues that these progressive reforms are what ensured the stability of the regime:https://newleftreview.org/sidecar/posts/the-roads-to-damascusBut for the last so many years, this carrot-and-stick approach has been off the table as sanctions have eliminated the possibility of any carrot.There’s another informative essay at RT:https://www.rt.com/news/609099-assad-syria-collapse-crisis/And if I may paste an excerpt:“Assad’s Syria had been rotting from within for years. The country was locked in a perpetual humanitarian and economic crisis, with 90% of Syrians living in poverty and widespread malnutrition. Desperate families took out loans just to buy food but couldn’t pay them back. Power outages crippled even Damascus, sometimes leaving the capital dark for 20 hours a day. Electricity prices soared by up to 585% in the spring of 2024 alone, pushing an already destitute population deeper into despair.“The Assad government offered no solutions – only mounting repression. Under crushing sanctions, Damascus couldn’t secure foreign loans, and with its oil fields under US-Kurdish control, there was nothing left to trade. Even Syria’s illicit drug trade, once a lifeline, couldn’t plug the gaping holes in state finances. Profits disappeared into the pockets of warlords and traffickers, not the state treasury.“Meanwhile, Assad’s underpaid, demoralized army, bled dry by years of civil war, continued to disintegrate. For a time, Iranian proxies like Hezbollah propped up his forces, but by 2024, they’d shifted their attention to fighting Israel. Attempts to draw Russia further into Syria’s quagmire fell flat. Moscow, busy elsewhere, had no interest in bailing Assad out.“So when the final crisis hit, Assad found himself alone. His allies stayed away, his army scattered, and an enraged, starving populace turned on the government. There was no one left to protect him.”
Felix Krull #435686 December 11, 2024 9:38 am 13
That aside, a country run by a distinct and distrusted minority is never going to be stable, especially when the minority is tiny. Unless it is backed up by a colonial empire: there’s a limit to the oppressive excesses a minority government will risk, while an empire-backed majority will often just wipe out the competition and start scheming against their Western benefactor. That’s why colonial powers usually choose to empower a minor local tribe over the dominant, like in Syria and Saudi and Libya. Of course, once the empire leaves, demographic realities will kick back in.
Tarl Cabot #435693 December 11, 2024 9:52 am 7
Ultimately, a ruling minority has one and only one strategy to maintain power- genocide. This can be accomplished either through subtraction or addition, or both.
Felix Krull #435702 December 11, 2024 10:15 am 17
Not when the minority is small enough to rely on the cooperation of the majority. Rule by ethnic minority is quite normal throughout history. Norman Britain, Macedon Egypt, Viking Rus, Visigothic Spain etc.
Ostei Kozelskii #435761 December 11, 2024 1:00 pm 4
And until very, very recently, Castillian Mexico.
Tarl Cabot #435771 December 11, 2024 3:12 pm 2
Additive methods of genocide include cultural assimilation, which basically boils down to down to taking their women, and the physical or psychological castration of the men you don’t kill.
DLS #435721 December 11, 2024 11:09 am 10
This is a good point. We did very well with the Shah of Iran and Mubarak in Egypt. Saddam Hussein was manageable until he was lured into Kuwait. Even Gaddafi was friendly at the end. After the U.S. tried to install democracy that no one wanted, look what we have in those countries now.
ray #435745 December 11, 2024 12:13 pm 12
Let’s see, Assad protected the Christian communities, and New Amerika is obsessed with spreading woke, feminism, and transgenderism around the globe. Not a match.D.C. and N.Y. hate hate hates! them some Christians, ooh baby. Old vet insurrectionists, gun-lovers, Bible imbibers ‘n church-goers is not Our Democracy. (Leaving aside that most Christians already converted to Progressivism quietly long ago. But anyways.)Who is New Amerika? Women, their ever-ally the homos, plus the banksters and the old money/occult elite families. Korporate Amerika, that handful of mega-corporations under which everything else is subsumed. The Left’s leaders are just SURE that a glorious New Age and Order is right around the corner, a techo-paradise. Ruled by . . . them.Old Bashar had to go.
pyrrhus #435685 December 11, 2024 9:37 am 10
Yes, apparently the Russians got tired of supporting the Alawites and their corrupt generals, who were probably bribed to stand down against the head-choppers…According to Martynov, the Assad Regime treated the Russians and their journalists poorly, despite Putin having saved their bacon twice in the last 15 years…And it’s clearly true that a battalion or two of Russian (or Ukrainian) troops would have sent HTS and the other terrorist groups packing very quickly…
Maxda #435700 December 11, 2024 10:08 am 10
Seems obvious that the Syrian senior officers were bribed and / or blackmailed into standing down. Since Arab enlisted have zero initiative on their own, they took off running when they realized they’d been betrayed.
thezman #435707 December 11, 2024 10:25 am 14
I think the Russians tried to make the best of things, but there was no saving Assad. The Syrian army was a mess and no amount of Russian military support would fix that problem. They will make the best of what comes next, which is most likely a regional war.
mikew #435723 December 11, 2024 11:11 am 7
The Russian half assed it 5 years ago when they let the head choppers congregate in Idlib. The job undone ended up undoing Syria. Russia also did nothing and said nothing while the Israelis Air Force had their way with Syria for the last 5 or 6 years. After their initial rescue of Syria in 2015, the Russians have not covered themselves in glory. Hell , the US slaughtered a bunch of Wagner guys and they did nothing.
The Wild Geese Howard #435736 December 11, 2024 11:46 am 3
Simplicius provides a good, evidence-backed argument in his latest post as to why taking Idlib and wiping out the terrorists there would not have been so simple. The short version is that the US and the Turks seemed to show they were ready to go to regional war over Idlib at that time.
TempoNick #435739 December 11, 2024 11:53 am 9
“The Ottomans tried to suppress them on multiple occasions, but also found them useful in roles requiring skill, like tax farming and managing the empire’s finances.”Sounds like they had a similar role that the Jews had under the Ottomans. Maybe that’s why, as you hinted above, the two were on reasonably friendly terms, at least unofficially.—–“That aside, a country run by a distinct and distrusted minority is never going to be stable, especially when the minority is tiny. This is why the Assad government had been ruthless at times when dealing with the Sunni majority. To keep the peace, the government had to make clear to anyone thinking otherwise that the government would use maximum force to maintain the peace. Minority rule is always made worse by the tactics necessary to maintain it.”Kind of like where we are at in many respects with our own government. We’ve got a minority ruling, financial and bureaucratic class imposing their values and prerogatives on the rest of the country, and they are increasingly brutal and ham-handed in how they go about it.—–“Now that the official policy of the United States is to spread chaos around the world, Assad was an easy target for the now familiar regime change operation.”It never ceases to amaze me how we’ve become the Soviet Union in its waning years, in so many different ways. That chaos we sow destroys people’s lives, destroys families, destroys what it took them a lifetime to build. We truly have become the Great Satan, the Evil Empire. We truly deserve to be considered despicable people, like many consider us to be.
TomA #435725 December 11, 2024 11:14 am 9
What was true for millennia is now in doubt in the modern age of technology and mass indoctrination via mass media. Or, at least that is the working hypothesis. In the fictional novel Brave New World, the drug “soma” quelled the masses and facilitated peaceful authoritarian rule; and we know how that ended. Europe is now the petrie dish of this experiment and it will be instructive to see how things turn out. Methinks it won’t be merely words of woke persuasion that solve this problem. A bloody cauldron awaits.
Hun #435690 December 11, 2024 9:45 am 8
Here is a video on the Chinese perspective of the events in Syria, that I happen to agree with:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NPyzL7EnD9I I don’t buy the argument that Russians got tired of supporting them. They are going to lose their military bases in Syria, if USrael succeeds in installing a US friendly government, which is now a real possibility.
Alex #435694 December 11, 2024 10:02 am 6
Its really up to the Turks to decide how much US/Foreign interference they want in the new protectorate. We don’t have the greatest history managing stable regimes in that part of the world. The Israelis and the Turks will have to come to some sort of accommodation.
DLS #435714 December 11, 2024 10:56 am 8
I doubt the US will get a friendly government based on our experience with Iran, Iraq, Afghanistan and Libya.
Maxda #435698 December 11, 2024 10:05 am 5
Tom Luongo this morning talking about how the Russians had been offering Assad a deal with stronger commitments, but he kept trying to play them off against the Arab League and others.https://rumble.com/v5y5eh5-760-tom-luongo-and-dave-collum.html
thezman #435704 December 11, 2024 10:20 am 22
Russian policy is to always make the most of the conditions that exist. There was not much they could do to change things. As to what happens next, just assume that whatever you want to happen, will not happen and whatever you fear will happen, will not happen. The Turks and the United States are about to learn it is never good to create chaos.
Severian #435692 December 11, 2024 9:47 am 7
Which factor is the most important, in your opinion — the Alawites as a cultural, genetic, or ideological minority? I think the best lens through which to view late-stage Soviet America is the lens of theocracy. They tried conversion through persuasion (the schools). They tried conversion by the sword (replacing the native population with foreigners). But they — the stupid, evil clowns who rule us — did seem to consciously realize that they’re a minority (of lunatics, in a majority of sane people). If that’s really the case, then AINO’s collapse will break along ideological lines. If it’s the other two, though, there will be different lessons. Syria will have object lessons however it goes, but it’d help to determine which is primary.
LineInTheSand #435708 December 11, 2024 10:25 am 10
If you are right, and AINO’s collapse breaks along ideological lines, this implies that some significant proportion of non-whites will align with traditional whites instead of their racial tribes, because of the Christianity or conservatism that they share with whites. I find it hard to imagine that many non-whites will side with traditional whites because of Christianity or liberty. Of course, there will be a few, but their proportions will be small, say, less than 5%. Maybe I’m wrong. Do you envision lots of blacks, mestizos, or asians casting their lot with white Christians, for example, against their own tribes?
Jack Dobson #435742 December 11, 2024 11:59 am 7
Which factor is the most important, in your opinion — the Alawites as a cultural, genetic, or ideological minority?How to disentangle the three in this case? The ideology flows directly from being a historically persecuted genetic and cultural minority since both Shia and Sunni consider Alawites heretical, the former to a far greater degree (Shia Iran allied with the Alawites more out of expediency than religious identity and its doctrinal disagreements pale in comparison to the Sunni House of Saud’s outright hatred). Ba’athism is an attempt to thread the needle with distinct ethnicities and cultures under the guise of socialism, but its purpose is to largely protect religious minorities*. There are few if any Alawites casting their lot with Sunnis because of actual ideological or cultural affinity; the ideology creates a pretext of a non-existent unity. Culture is downstream from genetics, of course.The primary difference between Syria and the United States is the vastness of the latter. That may in fact allow for breakaway ideological states in addition to the traditional racial and cultural separations, but over time those in the former will identify and ally with the latter based on immutable traits.*As happened in Iraq, the Shabbos goy United States now has paved the wave for another Christian genocide to appease ol’ Massa Schlomo; the next time you see some Republican hack/stooge proclaiming their Christianity, remember that this political party has caused the slaughter of Christians on a scale that would make the Ottomans blush.
Alzaebo #435755 December 11, 2024 12:51 pm 6
Simplicius offers a fat reed: Israel may be creating two golems, and I say three.She has bought time and intends to be a power, but a rough justice will come.Nourishing the Turk and blockading the Shia is a temporary victory. Grown stronger, ambitious Ottomans and a consolidating Sunni caliphate will gang up on Israel’s Eretz designs. (Egypt will aid, nursing past grievances and fresh insults. And HTS is already talking about next year in Jerusalem.)Hamas and Hiz’b’allah are only branches while the trunk of Iran is still whole.Since Iran’s direct line to the Med is blocked, they will turn their efforts to the proposed ITSC north-south corridor linking the Baltic with the Arabian Ocean, a joint desire by India, Iran, and the Arabs. (Also Mackinder’s nightmare.) As an oil producer, why shouldn’t Iran join Russia and look east? Even run corridors into the ‘Stans and Russia herself?(If justice were served, a Kurdistan would be born in Idlib. They want their own state, too.)The downside is that ZATO, by sundering the re-unification of the White world, is also opening the gates to a rekindled Conquest. Maybe the minority state can save herself by providing good service to the golems she’s creating.
Dutchboy #435730 December 11, 2024 11:36 am 5
Apparently, the economic sanctions hurt Syria badly enough that Assad could no longer pay his soldiers. When the jihadis attacked, the Syrian army just went home.
The Wild Geese Howard #435738 December 11, 2024 11:49 am 8
There is a video from autumn 2019 where US spook Dana Sproul describes exactly how the illegal US occupation forces were explicitly sited to strangle Syria economically to destabilize the Assad regime.
Ketchup-stained Griller #435752 December 11, 2024 12:45 pm 2
Stroul?
The Wild Geese Howard #435801 December 11, 2024 10:11 pm 0
You got me and my fuzzy memory man! +1
Zulu Juliet #435746 December 11, 2024 12:16 pm 4
ISIS is the armed expression of Sunni resistance to the Shia rising to power in Iraq. One the U.S. declared democracy in Iraq, the majority Shia took their opportunity to get revenge on the Sunnis. The surge and its aftermath took a lot of the wind out of the Sunni resistance, but there was no way to stamp it out, so it metastisized into ISIS, and grew in Syria to eventually take over the place. Maybe this is a more stable set-up in the long run, with the Shia running Iraq and the Sunnis running Syria.
Jannie #435713 December 11, 2024 10:55 am 3
Excellent piece!
Alzaebo #435741 December 11, 2024 11:58 am 1
This really is, it is top-notch.
Fast-Turtle #435798 December 11, 2024 9:30 pm 1
I see Goldman Sachs Murphy, the only rich dude that still had fucked up teeth… apparently could go to WAR against a gym. Sending in his tall, Jersey Staties, with their 10 gallon hats. But he has no clue how to deal with the drones. Maybe they have some nice veneers for this ugly crook?
Fast-Turtle #435797 December 11, 2024 9:25 pm 1
OT, perhaps. The Iranian Mother Ship is scheduled to pick up Barry Soetoro and take him back to his home.
Vegetius #435795 December 11, 2024 8:19 pm 1
#100 : George Will lives.
DYSPEPSIA GENERATION Blog Archive Minority Rule #435766 December 11, 2024 1:40 pm 1
[…] ZMan digs into history. […]


Back to top